We use cookies to enhance your experience on our website. By continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. You can change your cookie settings at any time.
Find out more
Jump to Content
Jump to Main Navigation
User Account
Personal Profile
See all online law products
More
About
Guided Tour
Subscriber Services
FAQs
Help
Contact Us
Search
Browse all
Content type
Case reports
Arbitral cases
Commentary and analysis
Book content
Journal articles
Yearbook articles
Investment treaty overviews (by jurisdiction)
Treaties
Multilateral treaties
Bilateral investment treaties
Other instruments and materials
Arbitral rules
Author
Arbitrators and Counsel
My Content
(0)
Recently viewed
(0)
Save Entry
My Searches
(0)
Recently viewed
(0)
Save Search
Print
Save
Cite
Email this content
Share Link
Copy this link, or click below to email it to a friend
Email this content
or copy the link directly:
https://oxia.ouplaw.com/abstract/10.1093/law/9780199654567.001.0001/law-9780199654567-miscMatter-8
The link was not copied. Your current browser may not support copying via this button.
Link copied successfully
Copy link
Sign in
You could not be signed in, please check and try again.
Username
Please enter your Username
Password
Please enter your Password
Forgot password?
Don't have an account?
Sign in via your Institution
You could not be signed in, please check and try again.
Sign in with your library card
Please enter your library card number
View translated passages only
Oxford Law Citator
Contents
Expand All
Collapse All
Preliminary Material
Dedication
Preface
Contents
Table of Cases
Table of Legislation
Algeria
Angola
Argentina
Australia
Bolivia
Brazil
Canada
Chile
Costa Rica
Cuba
Democratic Peoples Republic of Korea
Democratic Republic of Congo
Ecuador
Egypt
Europe
France
Ghana
India
Japan
Kenya
Kuwait
Nigeria
Peru
Peoples Republic of China
Philippines
Republic of Korea
Republic of Panama
Saudi Arabia
Senegal
South Africa
Soviet Union
Sudan
Tunisia
Turkey
United Kingdom
United States
Statutes
Codes, Rules and Regulations
Venezuela
Vietnam
Table of Agreements, Conventions, Rules, and Treaties
List of Abbreviations
Main Text
Part I International Investment and the Law
1 The Nature and Significance of International Investment
1.1 The Meaning of Investment
1.2 The Forms of Investment
(a) Property and Contractual Rights Resulting from Investments
(b) Control Attributes of Investments
(c) Enterprise Forms
1.3 The Nature of International Investors
(a) Private Investors
(b) State Investors
(c) International Organizations
(d) Mixed Enterprises
1.4 Investors and the Role of Return and Risk
1.5 The Nature of International Investment
1.6 Forms of International Investment
(a) Foreign Direct Investment.
(b) Foreign Portfolio Equity Investment.
(c) International Loans.
(d) International Bonds.
(e) Suppliers’ and Others’ Credits.
(f) Other Contractual Arrangements.
1.7 State and Investor Interests Shaping the Laws of International Investment
(a) Host Country Interests
(i) Benefits and Rewards of Foreign Investment
(ii) The Risks and Costs of Foreign Investment
(b) Investor Interests
(c) Investor Home Country Interests
1.8 Investment and Trade: What’s the Difference?
2 The Relationship between Law and International Investment
2.1 Introduction
2.2 Law Enhances or Diminishes the Predictability of Investment Transactions
2.3 Law Increases or Reduces Associated Transaction Costs
2.4 Law is an Instrument to Direct, Control, and Encourage International Capital Flows
2.5 Law Defines and Regulates Investment Rights, Responsibilities, and Relationships
2.6 Law is a Means to Resolve Investment Disputes
3 Three Legal Frameworks for International Investment: National, Contractual, and International
3.1 The Investment Frameworks in General
3.2 The National Legal Framework
3.3 The Contractual Framework
a) Investor Contracts.
b) Enterprise Supply, Finance, and Sales Contracts.
c) Insurance Contracts.
d) State Contracts.
3.4 The International Legal Framework
(a) International conventions
(b) International Custom
(c) General principles of law,
(d) International Organizations and Institutions.
3.5 The Interrelationships of the Three Legal Frameworks
Part II The National Legal Framework
4 Factors Shaping National Legal Frameworks for International Investment
4.1 Introduction
4.2 Four Dominant Attitudes toward International Investment
(a) Pro-international Investment Theories
(b) Anti-international Investment Theories
(c) Negotiation Theories of International Investment
(d) Structural Theories of International Investment
4.3 National Economic Systems and Development Models
(a) In General
(b) Models and Systems in the Developing World
(c) The Nature of Development Model I
(i) Public Ordering and State Planning
(ii) Reliance on Public Sector Enterprises
(iii) Restriction and Regulation of the Private Sector
(iv) Restrictions on Foreign Investment and Influence in the Economy
(d) Implications of Development Model I for National Legal Systems
(e) The Emergence of Development Model II
(i) Reliance on Markets and Private Ordering
(ii) Privatization
(iii) Deregulation
(iv) Opening Economies
(f) Implications of Development Model II for National Legal Systems
(g) Conclusion: Future Models?
5 National Regulation of the Exit and Entry of Capital
5.1 Introduction
5.2 The Authority of States to Regulate International Capital Movements
5.3 Regulation of Capital Outflows
(a) Controls to Preserve Domestic Savings for Domestic Use
(b) Controls to Generate Government Revenue
(c) Controls to Manage and Allocate Credit
(d) Controls to Correct a Balance of Payments Deficit
(e) Controls for Foreign Policy Purposes
5.4 Regulation of Capital Inflows
6 National Regulation of Foreign Investment
6.1 National Foreign Investment Policy and Law
6.2 Regulation of Foreign Direct Investment
6.3 The Definition of Permitted Investments
(a) In General
(b) Sector Prohibitions and Limitations
Investing Across Borders,
(c) Specification of Desired Investments
(d) Defined Contributions to the National Economy
(e) Joint Venture Requirements
(f) Performance Requirements
(g) Restrictions on the Acquisition of Land and Natural Resources
6.4 Incentives and Guarantees Offered to Foreign Investment
(a) In General
(b) A General Theory of Investment Incentives
(c) Types of Investment Incentives and Guarantees
(d) The Effectiveness of Investment Incentives and Guarantees
1) Do the incentives actually encourage desired investment?
2) Are the benefits to be gained by the host country from the investment worth the cost of the incentives?
3) Are incentives encouraging undesirable behavior in the investor?
6.5 Controls over Foreign Investment Operations
(a) In General
(b) Price Controls
(c) Foreign Exchange Controls
(d) Management Controls
(e) Financial Controls
(f) Changing Controls
6.6 Administration of Direct Foreign Investment Regulations
(a) In general
(b) Foreign Investment Screening or Registration
(c) Foreign Investment Promotion
(d) Foreign Investment Monitoring
6.7 Host Government Investment Approvals
6.8 Privatization of State Assets as a Means to Encourage Foreign Equity Investment
(a) Background
(b) Reasons for and Objectives of Privatization Programs
(i) Relief of Governmental Budget Deficits
(ii) Relief from Indebtedness
(iii) Improvement of Enterprise Efficiency
(iv) Increased Competition
(v) Development of Private Enterprises
(vi) Development of Wider Business Ownership
(vii) Implementation of Pre-existing Policies
(viii) Conditionality Imposed by International Financial Institutions
(c) The Legal Basis of Privatization
(d) The Privatization Process
(e) Types of Privatization Transaction
(i) Public Offering of Shares
(ii) Private Sale of Shares
(iii) Sale of State Assets
(iv) Reorganization into Component Parts
(v) New Private Investment into an Existing State Enterprise
(vi) Management and/or Employee Buyout
(vii) Leases
(viii) Concessions and Management Contracts
(f) Postprivatization Control Devices
6.9 National Regulation of Foreign Portfolio Equity Investment
6.10 National Regulation of International Debt Investments
(a) International Debt Investments in General
(b) Regulatory Frameworks for International Debt Investments
(c) The Special Nature and Problems of Sovereign Debt Investments
(i) Making Sovereign Debt Obligations
(ii) Performing Sovereign Debt Obligations
6.11 Debt-to-Equity Conversions
(a) Background
(b) History
(c) Types of Conversion Transactions
(i) Debt Capitalization Transactions
(ii) Debt-for-Equity Transactions
(iii) Debt-for-Local-Currency Transactions
(d) Reasons for the Development of Debt-Equity Conversions
(e) The Structure of Debt–Equity Transactions
7 The Challenges of Legal Change
7.1 The Nature of Legal Change
7.2 The Forces for Legal Change
(a) In General
(b) Financial and Political Crises
(c) Changes in Government or Prevailing Ideology
(d) Perceived Economic and Political Necessity
(e) Governmental Desire to Improve the Investment Bargain
(f) The Advancement of Public Welfare
7.3 Investor Strategies for Coping with the Risk of Legal Change
(a) International Law Strategies
(b) Diplomatic Strategies
(c) Protective Business Strategies
(i) Governmental and Public Relations
(ii) Asset Protection
(d) Third-Party Insurance Strategies
(e) Contractual Strategies
(i) Choice-of-Law Provisions
(ii) Dispute Settlement Provisions
(iii) Sovereign Immunity Waivers
(iv) Stabilization Clauses
Part III The Contractual Legal Framework
8 The Nature and Functions of the Contractual Framework for Investments
8.1 In General
8.2 Investment Contracts as Legal Instruments
(a) The Legal Basis
(b) State Contracts
8.3 The Economic and Social Functions of Investment Contracts
(a) Risk Allocation
(b) Investment Planning
(c) Investment Control
(d) Benefit Extraction
(e) Regulation and Governance
(f) Conclusion
9 The Negotiation of International Investment Contracts
9.1 The Role of Negotiation in the Investment Process
9.2 The Nature of the Negotiation Process
(a) Prenegotiation
(b) Conceptualization
(c) Detail Arrangement
9.3 Barriers to Negotiating an International Investment
9.4 The Barrier of the Negotiating Environment
9.5 The Barrier of Foreign Laws and Governments
9.6 The Barrier of Ideological Differences
9.7 The Barrier of Foreign Organizations and Bureaucracies
9.8 The Barrier of Multiple Currencies
9.9 The Barrier of Political Instability and Sudden Change
9.10 The Barrier of Cultural Differences
(a) In General
(b) The Meaning of Culture
(c) The Elements of Culture
(d) Culture’s Effect on Investment Negotiation
9.11 Negotiating Investment Contracts with Foreign Governments
(a) In General
(b) Government Attitudes toward Negotiation
(c) Governments Feel Different
(d) The Special Negotiating Powers of Foreign Governments
(i) Power No 1: The Power of Monopoly
(ii) Power No 2: The Power of Privilege and Immunity
(iii) Power No 3: The Power of Representing the Public Interest
(iv) Power No 4: The Power of Protocol and Form
(e) Governments’ Special Negotiating Constraints
(i) Constraint No 1: Negotiating Rules
(ii) Constraint No 2: Constituents
(iii) Constraint No 3: The Political Imperative
(iv) Constraint No 4: Operational Norms
1 Revenue norms.
2 Resource allocation norms.
3 Objectives norms.
(f) A Government Deal is Never Done
(g) Coping with Corruption in Government Negotiations
(h) Guidelines for Negotiating with Governments
9.12 Negotiating Long-Term Investment Contracts
1 A Signed Contract Does Not Necessarily Create an International Business Relationship.
2 An International Deal is a Continuing Negotiation.
3 Don’t Rush Prenegotiation.
4 Consider a Role for Mediation or Conciliation in the Deal.
10 The Nature and Content of International Investment Contracts
10.1 Introduction
10.2 Wholly Owned Foreign Direct Investments
10.3 International Joint Ventures
10.4 International Joint Venture Contracts
(a) In General
(b) Preliminary Joint Venture Agreements: The Case of the Kenana Sugar Company (Phase I)
(c) The Structure of Joint Venture Agreements
10.5 The Content of International Joint Venture Agreements
(a) In General
(b) Preambles and Recitals
(c) Organization and Capitalization
(d) Control and Management
(e) Reimbursement of Preincorporation Expenses
(f) Financial Policies
(g) Other Partner Obligations and Guarantees
(h) Accounting and Auditors
(i) Transfer of Shares
(j) Applicable Law and Dispute Settlement
(k) Termination
10.6 International Investment in Infrastructure
(a) Background
(b) Project Finance Transactions
(c) The Advantages and Risks of International Infrastructure Investments
(i) For Host Countries
(ii) For Foreign Investors
(d) Parties to International Infrastructure Investments
(e) The Infrastructure Approval Process
(f) Financing International Infrastructure Projects
(g) The Legal and Contractual Framework for Infrastructure Investments
(h) Concession Contract Provisions
(i) Concession Rights and Obligations
(ii) The Project Company
(iii) Timing
(iv) Land Acquisition
(v) Appointment of an Independent Engineer
(vi) Fees, Tariffs, Tolls, and Compensation
(vii) Operation and Maintenance
(viii) Profit Sharing and Other Payments to the Government
(ix) Termination
(x) Governing Law and Dispute Settlement
(xi) Other Provisions
(i) Other Project Contracts
(i) Consortium Agreements
(ii) The Project Company
(iii) The Construction Contract
(iv) Operations and Management Agreement
(v) Loan Agreements
10.7 A Case Study of Infrastructure Investment: The Dabhol Power Company in India
(a) Background
(b) Negotiating the Dabhol Project
(c) The Contractual Framework of the Dabhol Project
10.8 International Loan Contracts
(a) Introduction
(b) The International Lending Process
(i) Commitment Letter
(ii) Mandate Letter
(iii) Syndicate Manager
(iv) Offering Memoranda
(v) Conclusion of a Definitive Loan Agreement
(c) The Provisions of the Loan Agreement
(d) Other Related Agreements
(i) Security Agreements
(ii) Guarantees
(iii) Inter-creditor Agreements
11 Political Risk Insurance
11.1 Political Risk
11.2 Political Risk Insurance
11.3 National Governmental Programs
11.4 The United States Overseas Private Investment Corporation (OPIC)
(a) Background
(b) Objectives
(c) Organizational Structure
(d) OPIC Investment Insurance in General
(e) OPIC Protection against Inconvertibility
(f) OPIC Protection against Expropriation
(g) OPIC Protection against Political Violence
(h) Eligible Investors
(i) Eligible Investments
(j) Eligible Host Countries
(k) Obtaining OPIC Political Risk Insurance
(l) Investor Claims Against OPIC
(m) Other OPIC Activities
11.5 Multilateral Political Risk Insurance Programs
11.6 The Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency (MIGA)
(a) Background
(b) Organizational Structure
(c) MIGA Investment Guarantee Operations
(i) Eligible Investors
(ii) Eligible Investments
(d) Risks Covered by MIGA
(i) Transfer and Convertibility Risks
(ii) Expropriation and Similar Measures
(iii) Breach of Contract
(iv) War and Civil Disturbance
(e) Other Conditions of a MIGA Guarantee
11.7 Private Sources of Political Risk Insurance
12 Contractual Stability, Instability, and Renegotiation
12.1 The Challenge of Contractual Stability
(a) The Parties’ Imperfect Contract
(b) Changing Circumstances
12.2 Defining Renegotiation
(a) Post-Contract Renegotiations
(b) Intra-Contract Renegotiations
(c) Extra-Contract Renegotiation
(d) Summary
12.3 Post-Contract Renegotiations
(a) Distinguishing Characteristics
(b) Principles to Guide Post-Contract Renegotiations
(i) Provide for Post-Contract Renegotiations in the Original Contract
(ii) Individually and Jointly Review the History of the Original Contract
(iii) Understand Thoroughly the Alternatives to a Renegotiated Contract
12.4 Intra-Contract Renegotiations
(a) Balancing Contractual Stability and Flexibility
(b) Approaches to Intra-Contract Renegotiation
(i) The Implicit Renegotiation Clause
(ii) Review Clauses
(iii) Automatic Adjustment Clauses
(iv) Open-Term Provisions
(v) Renegotiation Clauses
12.5 Extra-Contract Renegotiation
(a) The Context of Extra-Contract Renegotiations
12.6 A Case of Extra-Contract Renegotiation: The Dabhol Power Project in India
(a) Background
(b) The Forces for Changing the Investment Agreement
(c) Renegotiating the Dabhol Project
(d) The Terms of the Renegotiated Investment Agreement
a Equity Participation.
b Output Capacity.
c Capital Costs.
d Power Tariff.
e Fuel.
f Environment.
g Other Terms.
(e) The Aftermath
(f) The Aftermath of the Aftermath
(g) The Lessons of Dabhol: Principles to Guide Extra-Contract Project Renegotiations
(i) Principles to Follow before Contractual Breakdown
1 Work to Create a Business Relationship between the Parties and Recognize that a Signed Contract Does Not Necessarily Create an International Business Relationship
2 Building a Relationship Takes Time, so Don’t Rush Negotiations and Use Negotiation Preliminaries Fully
3 Consider Providing for Renegotiation in Appropriate Transactions
4 Consider a Role for Mediation or Conciliation in the Deal
(ii) Renegotiation Principles after Contractual Breakdown
1 Hostile, Belligerent, or Moralistic Responses to Demands for Renegotiation are Generally Ineffective
2 It is Important to Understand the Basis of the Other Side’s Demand for Renegotiation.
3 Evaluate the Worth of the Claim for Breach of Contract against the Value of a Continuing Relationship with the Other Side
4 Look for Ways to Create Value in the Renegotiation
5 The Parties should Fully Understand the Alternatives to Succeeding in the Renegotiation—Especially their Costs
6 Make Sure All Necessary Parties in the Renegotiation are Involved Either Directly or Indirectly
7 The Right Process for the Renegotiation is Important
8 Consider a Role for a Mediator in the Renegotiation Process
12.7 Conclusion
Part IV The International Legal Framework
13 The Foundations of the International Legal Framework for Investment
13.1 In General
13.2 International Conventions
13.3 International Custom
13.4 General Principles of Law
13.5 Customary International Law and General Principles of Law Governing Investment
(a) Introduction
(b) Standard of Treatment Owed to Aliens by Host States
(c) The Application and Enforcement of a Minimum Standard
13.6 Customary International Law Concerning Expropriation and Breach of State Contracts
(a) In general
(b) Taking under International Law
(c) Public Purpose
(d) Discrimination
(e) Compensation
(f) Breaches of State Contracts
13.7 Challenges to the Capital-Exporting States’ Position on International Investment Law
(a) Introduction
(b) The Soviet Challenge
(c) The Latin American Challenge
(d) The Postcolonial Challenge
13.8 Perceived Deficiencies of International Investment Law
14 The Treatification of International Investment Law
14.1 Introduction
14.2 Historical Background of the Treatification Process
(a) The Early Beginnings
(b) The Emergence of a Treaty Framework for Investment Protection in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries
(c) Further Developments in the Eighteenth, Nineteenth, and Early Twentieth Centuries
(d) From World War I until World War II
(e) The Immediate Aftermath of World War II
(f) The Later Post-World War II Years
(i) Bilateral Efforts
(ii) Multilateral Efforts
(g) The Development of the Bilateral Investment Treaty (BIT) and the Creation of the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID)
(h) The Gathering Momentum of the BIT Movement
(i) The Development of Multilateral Regional and Sector Investment Agreements
(1) Arab States Investment Agreement
(2) ASEAN Investment Agreement
(3) Mercosur Investment Treaties
(4) Comesa Treaty
(5) North American Free Trade Agreement
(6) The Energy Charter Treaty
(7) Dominican Republic–Central America–United States Free Trade Agreement
(CAFTA-DR)
(j) The Evolution of BIT Provisions into Free Trade Agreements
(k) Toward a Global Treaty on Investment
(l) Conclusion
14.3 The Objectives of the Movement to Negotiate Investment Treaties
14.4 The Primary Objectives of Investment Treaties
(a) Investment Protection
(b) Investment Promotion
14.5 Secondary Objectives of Investment Treaties
(a) Market Liberalization
(b) Relationship Building
(c) Domestic Investment Encouragement
(d) Improved Governance and a Strengthened Rule of Law
14.6 Long-Term Goals of Investment Treaties
14.7 The Treaty Negotiation Process
(a) Bilateral Treaty Processes
(b) Multilateral Negotiation Processes
14.8 Conclusion
15 The Nature and Content of Investment Treaties
15.1 Introduction
15.2 Treaty Structure
15.3 Treaty Title and Statement of Purpose
15.4 Definitions and Scope of Application of Investment Treaties
(a) In General
(b) “Investments” Covered by Investment Treaties
(c) Limitations on Definitions of “Investment”
(i) Legal Requirements
(ii) Temporal Requirements
(iii) Sector Requirements
(iv) Territorial Requirements
(v) Approved Project Requirements
(c) Definitions of “Investors” Covered by the Treaty
(i) Natural Persons as “Investors”
(ii) Companies and other Legal Entities as “Investors”
15.5 Investment Promotion, Admission, and Establishment
(a) Investment Promotion
(b) Admission and Establishment of Investments
1 Admission according to National Law.
2 Grants of a Relative Right of Establishment.
3 Grants of an Absolute Right of Establishment.
(c) Performance Requirements
15.6 General Standards of Treatment of Foreign Investments
(a) Fair and Equitable Treatment
(b) Full Protection and Security
(c) Unreasonable or Discriminatory Measures
(d) International Law
(e) Contractual Obligations (“the Umbrella Clause”)
(f) National and/or Most-Favored-Nation Treatment
15.7 Monetary Transfers
15.8 Expropriation and Dispossession
15.9 Operational and Other Conditions
15.10 Losses from Armed Conflict or Internal Disorder
15.11 The Consequences of Treaty Violations
15.12 Dispute Settlement
15.13 Treaty Exceptions, Amendments, and Terminations
15.14 Conclusion
Part V Conclusion
16 The Interaction of the Three Legal Frameworks
16.1 In General
16.2 The National Law–Contractual Framework Interaction
16.3 The National Law–International Law Interaction
16.4 The Contractual Framework–International Law Interaction
Further Material
Index
Sign up for alerts
Table of Legislation
From:
The Three Laws of International Investment: National, Contractual, and International Frameworks for Foreign Capital
Jeswald W. Salacuse
Content type:
Book content
Product:
Investment Claims [IC]
Published in print:
01 February 2013
ISBN:
9780199654567
Prev
|
Next
[18.232.179.37]
18.232.179.37